お知らせ
GNP Co-hosted an International Seminar on “Who Governs Deep-Sea Mining? A Battle between Global Governance and National Governance"
On November 16, 2026, the seminar “Who Governs Deep-Sea Mining? A Battle between Global Governance and National Governance,” co-organized by the Global Network Program, was held. The seminar featured Dr. Lai-Ha Chan of the University of Technology Sydney, Australia.
The seminar examined how global and national governance compete in regulating deep-sea mining in areas beyond national jurisdiction. The deep seabed contains critical minerals essential to the transition to green energy and the development of the digital economy. Interest in extracting these resources has increased amid intensifying competition between China and the United States. At the same time, Dr. Chan highlighted continuing concerns about the environmental consequences and commercial viability of deep-sea mining.
Using a constructivist and interpretive approach, Dr. Chan analyzed the institutions and state behavior surrounding deep-sea mining. She focused particularly on two principles: the “common heritage of humankind” established under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) and the “freedom of the high seas.” She explained how the International Seabed Authority (ISA), the United States, and China interpret these concepts differently. She also demonstrated that the value and critical importance assigned to deep-sea minerals are socially constructed and change in response to technological, economic, and security developments. Dr. Chan then introduced the ongoing debate surrounding the Mining Code, which the ISA is developing to regulate the commercial exploitation of deep-seabed mineral resources. She explained that the prolonged negotiations reflect disagreements over how revenues from mining should be distributed among contractors, the ISA, and developing countries. Other unresolved issues include the effects on future generations and the design of compensation mechanisms for environmental damage.
The seminar also addressed the approaches taken by the United States and China. The United States has not ratified UNCLOS and has sought to pursue deep-sea mining outside the ISA framework by emphasizing the freedom of the high seas. However, several questions remain about the feasibility of this approach, including whether American companies could conduct extraction, transportation, and processing without international cooperation and whether licenses issued by the United States would receive international recognition. China, by contrast, is an active participant in the ISA and holds the largest number of exploration contracts. Dr. Chan explained how China, which once supported the principle of the common heritage of humankind as a developing country, has reinterpreted this principle following its economic and technological rise. China has increasingly replaced the language of the common “heritage” of humankind with that of the common “interest” of humankind. This change suggests a growing emphasis on commercial exploitation rather than the redistribution of benefits to other developing countries.
The presentation further highlighted the considerable uncertainty surrounding the investment required for commercial mining, the quantity and market value of minerals that could be extracted, and liability for environmental damage. Against this background, a moratorium on deep-sea mining is emerging as an increasingly mainstream international position. Even if an international regulatory framework is established, commercial mining in areas beyond national jurisdiction may remain limited. Mining may instead advance within countries’ exclusive economic zones or continental shelves under domestic law. Dr. Chan therefore explained that deep-sea mining may be governed globally in name but nationally in practice. Regarding Japan, Dr. Chan discussed its interest in mining rare-earth-rich mud within its exclusive economic zone around Minamitorishima. Japan’s approach reflects a preference for national governance shaped by concerns about economic security. However, extraction remains costly and its commercial feasibility is uncertain. Japan also continues to depend on China for the midstream processing of rare earths. Diversifying sources of extraction alone may therefore be insufficient to resolve Japan’s economic security challenges.
A total of 25 students and faculty members participated in the seminar. During the question-and-answer session, participants raised questions about why landlocked countries such as Rwanda and Switzerland support a moratorium on deep-sea mining; how changes in China’s economic and political position have transformed its national identity and interpretation of the common heritage of humankind; and why the study adopted a constructivist and interpretive research approach. These questions led to an active exchange of views. The seminar provided participants with a valuable opportunity to compare international institutions and national policies governing deep-sea mineral resources and to deepen their understanding of the relationship between global and national governance.